

Affiliate link. As an eBay Partner, Junk Wax Museum may earn from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you. Opens in a new tab.


Affiliate link. As an eBay Partner, Junk Wax Museum may earn from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you. Opens in a new tab.
Deion Sanders was one of the most electric athletes of the era in either sport, and his 1989 Score #246 is the rookie card the football hobby settles on. It sits inside the legendary 1989 Score football rookie class alongside Barry Sanders, Troy Aikman, Derrick Thomas, and Michael Irvin, a set so stacked with future Hall of Famers that it may be the deepest single-set RC class in football card history. Deion belongs here as the Prime Time anchor of the football wing, the two-sport phenomenon who is the only athlete ever to play in both a Super Bowl and a World Series, and the card that captured the beginning of a HOF cornerback career the day the Falcons made him the fifth overall pick.
Deion was Prime Time before Prime Time meant anything to anyone else. The high step, the gold chains, the swagger. He returned a punt for a touchdown in his first NFL game and never turned the celebration off. His 1989 Score rookie was the football card everybody knew, from the deepest rookie class of the era, and pulling it meant you had someone who was going to be on your television for the next fourteen years. Kids kept the Sanders, Aikman, and Deion together in the same top-loader, the 1989 Score football trinity.
1989 Score football is one of the greatest single rookie-class sets in card history, and Deion Sanders at #246 is one of its three flagship names alongside Barry Sanders #257 and Troy Aikman #270. Overproduced like the rest of late-80s Score, so raw copies trade in the $5-15 range, but the depth of the class and Deion's cultural weight keep demand steady. Deion delivered on the marketing bet Score made, playing fourteen NFL seasons with the Falcons, 49ers, Cowboys, Redskins, and Ravens, winning two Super Bowls, and cementing himself as arguably the best cover cornerback of the modern era. His parallel MLB career, nine seasons across the Yankees, Braves, Reds, and Giants, made him the only athlete to play in both a Super Bowl and a World Series. The Score rookie is the card that captured the moment before all of that started.
Base #246 in the 1989 Score football set is canonical. Deion has other 1989 rookies (Pro Set #486, Topps Traded #101T on the football side, and update-set baseball rookies) but the Score football is the flagship. The 1989 Score football class is one of the most reprinted designs in modern tribute product (Panini Chronicles, Leaf Memories) and Deion is one of the most-frequent tribute subjects alongside Sanders and Aikman. Condition is the main variable; centering and edge wear on the color-blocked border affect grade. No error variations of note on #246.
Card #246 from the 1989 Score football set, front shows Deion Sanders in an Atlanta Falcons uniform with the color-blocked 1989 Score border. The back is the Score football layout with a bio and stats on lighter stock. Confirm #246 and the Score branding to separate it from his 1989 Pro Set #486 and 1989 Topps Traded #101T football rookies. The Falcons uniform and the specific 1989 Score color-blocked border identify this version.
Other cards that competed for this slot in the JW50, and why they didn't make the cut.
The Pro Set Deion is the mass-produced version, printed in the same overwhelming quantities that would define Pro Set's short life. Cheap raw, cheap graded, everywhere. It loses the slot because 1989 Score is the deeper, more prestigious set and the one collectors treat as the true Deion rookie.
Deion's 1990 UD baseball Star Rookie #13 captures the 'wait, he plays baseball too?' moment and is the most-collected Deion baseball card. It loses the slot because Deion is a football-first legend and the Score rookie is his flagship. The UD is the second collectible if you want to represent his cross-sport story.