1989 Score #257 Barry Sanders (front)
1989 Score #257 Barry Sanders (back)
View current eBay listings →

Affiliate link. As an eBay Partner, Junk Wax Museum may earn from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you. Opens in a new tab.

#15
Football & Hockey

Barry Sanders

1989 · Score · #257
Overall rank
#15 of 50
Year
1989
Brand
Score
Card #
257
Sport
football
Card type
rookie
Wanted Instantly remembered
Raw
$52.67
$50.28 - $55.06
conf A · n=7
PSA 8
$80.95
$76.85 - $85.05
conf A · n=4
PSA 9
$192
$183 - $202
conf A · n=5
PSA 10
$2,250
$2,120 - $2,380
conf B · n=9
Fair Market Value · 7-day winsorized median · as of 2026-07-21
Price history

Population Report

Grading census
Total graded
37,334
PSA graded only
PSA 10 population
2,692
8.1% overall gem rate
Grade distribution · PSA 1 to 10 (all graders)
Grade 10
2,692
Grade 9
13,969
Grade 8
14,752
Grade 7
2,837
Grade 6
1,397
Grade 5
396
Grade 4
153
Grade 3
49
Grade 2
21
Grade 1
11

Why It Belongs

No football class of the era ran deeper than 1989 Score, and Sanders is its best rookie. The 1989 Score set gave us Sanders, Aikman, Deion, and Thurman Thomas, and Sanders is the pick of the litter, cleanest design, best photo, and a Hall of Fame career that ended on his own terms. It belongs here as the football equivalent of the Griffey moment: a rookie every collector wanted from a landmark set. Barry Sanders was the most electric running back since Jim Brown, and his Score rookie is the card that captured him at the start of the ride.

What Every Kid Remembered

Barry made people miss and fall down. His highlights were unreal, and his 1989 Score rookie was the football card to have. That set was loaded, everybody knew it, and pulling the Sanders felt like winning. Kids traded stacks for him. The Lions weren't good, but Barry was appointment television every Sunday, and owning his rookie meant you had one of the best cards in the hobby. You kept it in a top-loader and defended him as the best back alive, which for a while he was.

The Hobby Story

Score's 1989 football set is remembered as one of the great rookie classes, headlined by Sanders at #257. Overproduced like the rest of late-80s product, so raw copies trade at $2-8, but Sanders's Hall of Fame career and highlight-reel legacy keep demand steady. High-grade copies carry a premium given the set's condition quirks. Sanders retiring while still dominant, walking away near the rushing record, added a layer of mystique that keeps his rookie among the most respected football cards of the junk-wax years.

Versions & Variations

Base card with no significant parallels or errors of note. Sanders has other 1989 rookies (Topps, Pro Set), and collectors generally rate the Score as the premier one for its photography and design. Condition is the main variable; centering and edge wear on the colored border affect grade. There are no scarce alternate printings to chase. Watch for the common centering issues that plague 1989 Score.

How to Identify It

Card #257, 1989 Score design with a color-blocked border, Sanders in a Lions uniform. The back is the Score layout with a write-up and stats on lighter stock. Confirm #257 and the Score branding to separate it from his Topps and Pro Set rookies. The clean action photo and colored border frame identify the Score version.

Also Considered

Other cards that competed for this slot in the JW50, and why they didn't make the cut.

1989 Pro Set Barry Sanders #494
1989 Pro Set Barry Sanders #494
Search on eBay →

The Pro Set Sanders is the mass-produced version, printed in the same overwhelming quantities that would define Pro Set's short life. Cheap raw, cheap graded, everywhere. It loses the slot because 1989 Score is the deeper, cleaner set and the one collectors treat as the true Sanders rookie.

1989 Topps Traded Barry Sanders #83T
1989 Topps Traded Barry Sanders #83T
Search on eBay →

The 1989 Topps Traded Sanders is Topps's late-season entry, sold only in the boxed Traded set and carrying a modest scarcity edge over the flagship. Real card, real design, real player. It loses the slot because Score's 1989 football set is the one that owns the class, and Sanders is Score's headliner.